Bioshock probably had the best story of any fps I've ever played. Other than that, I wasn't particularly blown away by the gameplay or anything else. The whole audiotape storytelling convention was ripped straight out of Doom 3 which I liked, but didn't make the game as original as it would have been had I not played Doom 3. This game is proof thought that a good story with alright gameplay can make an otherwise good game great.
