Communism: Dirty and Stupid or Just Stupid?

No I did, you've never said anything that convinced me that your nonsense could be maintained.

this


Communism can be maintained because the people will want it too.

this


Communism can be maintained because the people will want it too.[/quote:2d1ggv3b]
Did you just quote and agree with yourself?

Did you just quote and agree with yourself?[/quote:ziqoe5yg]
I referenced the post I wanted him to read.

this


Communism can be maintained because the people will want it too.[/quote:36bvsf97]

Thats a wonderful opinion you have there, but I whole heartedly disagree, as I said you never said anything to convince me otherwise.

I like how you assumed that was an undefeatable argument so I mustn't have read it. LMAO

By it's very nature communism needs everyone to actually BE the same for it to operate in a social libertarian format, and that same person must be dedicated worker for no benefits who likes all different sorts of manual labour.

Otherwise people would be crazy and have "idea's" and "opinion's" and might just want their life to be different. Or in your anarchist nonsense they wouldn't work enough in the right area's and the disorganization would fuck everyone until someone starts up a wonderful government again.

Thats a wonderful opinion you have there, but I whole heartedly disagree, as I said you never said anything to convince me otherwise.

I like how you assumed that was an undefeatable argument so I mustn't have read it. LMAO

By it's very nature communism needs everyone to actually BE the same for it to operate in a social libertarian format, and that same person must be dedicated worker for no benefits who likes all different sorts of manual labour.

Otherwise people would be crazy and have "idea's" and "opinion's" and might just want their life to be different. Or in your anarchist nonsense they wouldn't work enough in the right area's and the disorganization would fuck everyone until someone starts up a wonderful government again.[/quote:l93wkn5a]
Um no, communism requires that everyone is equal on a social level, not a human level.

Just a qestion. Am I as equal as someone that does two times as much work as me or is he more equal? Furthermore, does he get any sort of reward for working harder?

Just a qestion. Am I as equal as someone that does two times as much work as me or is he more equal? Furthermore, does he get any sort of reward for working harder?[/quote:1t5kz33m]
Under 100% pure communism, people work completely on a voluntary basis.

Just a qestion. Am I as equal as someone that does two times as much work as me or is he more equal? Furthermore, does he get any sort of reward for working harder?[/quote:6ojq3v20]
Under 100% pure communism, people work completely on a voluntary basis.[/quote:6ojq3v20]

What if no one wants to work and they move to an imperialist country where people do the work for them.

Just a qestion. Am I as equal as someone that does two times as much work as me or is he more equal? Furthermore, does he get any sort of reward for working harder?[/quote:nilwk4ha]
Under 100% pure communism, people work completely on a voluntary basis.[/quote:nilwk4ha]

What if no one wants to work and they move to an imperialist country where people do the work for them.[/quote:nilwk4ha]
What if the sun explodes?

I dont know.

Just a qestion. Am I as equal as someone that does two times as much work as me or is he more equal? Furthermore, does he get any sort of reward for working harder?[/quote:30mmflm5]
Under 100% pure communism, people work completely on a voluntary basis.[/quote:30mmflm5]
Oh goody! I get to work for an hour a day only and fuck around and get paid the same amount of money my hardworking neighbor does!

Just a qestion. Am I as equal as someone that does two times as much work as me or is he more equal? Furthermore, does he get any sort of reward for working harder?[/quote:2uw0ewqa]
Under 100% pure communism, people work completely on a voluntary basis.[/quote:2uw0ewqa]

No, it just means everyone gets paid equally regardless of the job they do. No sitting on your arse.

Just a qestion. Am I as equal as someone that does two times as much work as me or is he more equal? Furthermore, does he get any sort of reward for working harder?[/quote:2z1u5r3i]
Under 100% pure communism, people work completely on a voluntary basis.[/quote:2z1u5r3i]

No, it just means everyone gets paid equally regardless of the job they do. No sitting on your arse.[/quote:2z1u5r3i]
Thats the dictatorship of the proletariat, socialism, mutualism, etc. Under communism there is a gift economy.

I hate the thought of working for other people.

Then start your own business.

People will naturally do what they feel is good.

I'm 16, and I mean I would hate to work in order to sustain someone else who does less work than me. Unless they desperately need it. i.e. faminists(?)

I'm 16, and I mean I would hate to work in order to sustain someone else who does less work than me. Unless they desperately need it. i.e. faminists(?)[/quote:15laeyut]
Then your vision of what you feel is good is not working inorder to sustain someone else who is freeloading.

I'm 16, and I mean I would hate to work in order to sustain someone else who does less work than me. Unless they desperately need it. i.e. faminists(?)[/quote:1b2xwhy0]
Then your vision of what you feel is good is not working inorder to sustain someone else who is freeloading.[/quote:1b2xwhy0]

No, I have no ideal vision. I am a realist and therefore I lack an ideal.

I'm 16, and I mean I would hate to work in order to sustain someone else who does less work than me. Unless they desperately need it. i.e. faminists(?)[/quote:u66v4tqs]
Then your vision of what you feel is good is not working inorder to sustain someone else who is freeloading.[/quote:u66v4tqs]

No, I have no ideal vision. I am a realist and therefore I lack an ideal.[/quote:u66v4tqs]
The majority of people have a vision of what is good.